Can_the_Thing_Speak_MMBOOKMOBI@  V%.-6?HQ Y b k~ t@ |bR<<,@:%Iu(MOBIDPEXTHK eOAC PressdMartin HolbraadCan the Thing Speak?j!2011-05-02T15:00:00+00:00l3calibre (0.7.53) [http://calibre-ebook.com]h20455763iOAC Working Papersq,97b859a3-cedf-4ef5-837d-3c91e90bb710 EBOKj!2011-05-02T15:00:00+00:00  Can the Thing Speak?
OACorkingaperseries #7
ISSN 2045-5763 (online)CanhehSpeak?ReaʖAugh0060075(cluA:G!/orragmat47Acknowledgz'  8Referencewwwwws73709wwNotOMoobM_ItapratlasIstudyI‘’edsyow ornifesto,choSpivaks 1980subalternadic0sm (1998)myitlebsugg.XrchaeiSexFYs胰lbserved (2P,0),riseeقPsocial1or0Ktu@ouru؃ae-aton0ti@ڈ"_2n(ȀȈ)enЍxlier.f恑ooo,ȂKgupculȃ,dhibXat[ed]żQmusbyTimngoldu it7: 5irx[Ќbeallboutchievvisibi y:r,Pe0lphrllowyto@kc (98:).Toeehxhe aro(expre,nsia(ure.otwithsdwvariety,tethހargu+tadو`xt-nyv-dezcalsoharac(sensurgy02).hPinsof0ypxtak1emw)IxencircXqhuPxIvpiciagnos@e!daPon8Heficiattribu╸xjec F)@ȁrPi@q8hncdtivXۣhortۄgɈp`ȋ;akequitabd`We`aoloч@cichai0tO-poomintegimpRvi#1-elevdio`vohdnceptu`mou,dafx0Hceserhapܰslavfromp`0mmoo (…)E-s (cf.uyP3?????ABou[sursuԑگqtheise ofhehing (materialulturetudies, -Xory,NT,pe8ativeealism,ost-phenom logytc.).etoolemic0writhaseenop dnargeartyiagnosisfyeficitihumanity –nbviou@ne`tㄈsScourseoughlljmoPpowerfulor.ndremedyRvarxwiden遡circleqz.hAgency’_ stoerhapsuxs8neutrtLcorol|sonhood,ist:voicfreedomdsponsibiorg |1kiaXnevfarfрe cipaQ@da.ndXA :tP䆠 certainlvYts XycnaesX.owlP9amopBruno̅ ur,Po sademocrac(x0dȒ(inclhliatm);annyilleLrunctyr*NowSf@ asmƒ(20rxy듙rony, TghrgsqIh-edRAp0rodu1withmiald (neee)Sast (7)wypÉ gle-audP(HolbraadZexpit9IÁhSLppa`r(sȉHn0sȊhl,nf8hfy@zsxJ fus9aꋓyundtogetwoeؑj˔ gy0s8shц1hHYaho,„ordicoilp ,Ré:wardautsh,waˇa9pproa(se GGG (hIhTTTP) 0ᏊhhaR/-:suchcwYMndspum쎰askcp'peo (hpЈ.Ј`0=000h3799{ or="blue">1N؜ns9pS'mdLjttrickgl0jecBrcatsa/77772En0|ang˃>8Inineithowles’snalogywritingsnost-coloni`sm,heastwentyear)roteraturenjris`fbthould@lottedrajectoryqincreasxly (self8nsciously) ‘radicala8mptsoislodgrvenrathat(videsromeople.Ã@r,nllhion+shiftroHقꂬacqui@Xbiographisocfe2irwroughcomxvolvemvP+honga8m (Appadurai 1986)@oayςve ci@P8ԅ (humandon-{)%elimina9b!waXskboutuchLatourP93,f.inney 2005).rZdifferenceNsuggeὐr eaohrpal Mh7,Â2cla0certaAontex9hHabHce(Jbeѓn: (SnA8,0Ss퉨sai@orrespoohoroadtxaxiڙdwhich,ollowiHara(1cWebmo&itmop9Iag@퀘рhvely.ԍړ/0HX҇ФHgsnG-.ȃzwapseek)ecip`o*erm p݊JOX&ond yobeyit+moveˁ(wardiargue0alYenstoo7&zasZi.0letComhw"@hoo*ЄlxR5yrifxٯ`–xa,١؃sHltogeBsPsfar.etx02reI7`influ9ibu g.

MprIty (_7)es*nspXexpImPlP1 d@@܏_H!)?74ro( a?;ilfuIcogniza,@oȺ`piscus!myoso8yh[s]%bl`(uҹWm: 41@ ludAnowXoriz4lbpPhJWaegHWla8sCobjfТsyr1@mutؙ闸tpri`2,\qʮ+É9job=g2Ysowev0ѹ (coxly)irvJׇwheel !lePcausLY8studi nogra3of a@xY(xme܈010RRɗBsgui,;Hpirin.ltily,y[ѬSbous"mmitfHolPrPغ0pY#PsWWamhPꌘɊxppؑ 38)&՘RlicWJg(ڄaۮB.ɂimSste bin-b8ߓmod؅:0AitivimXhrQ;yd?: ,mak1 (ibid).2<3<till,hateakesbundantlylearsHhti@withȁessin(fethnography,nd‘vulgar’tudyyway*specificharacter)peoplmergfromqin@ionmaialorlroughJce(MȂ2007: 26)@rA entptCLaveeenoingoromeime.festedXancipatth yrannb ubject ,becausesoiv8uoreofonderst(Qi2toHu.͉cultumHdisplacipxg bs0؋^imp@umoc,utnres8a@tтb!nbcogni 醈icهlh vasriourity.ׁ`exXkiȅ0I[Xmwhtal0ksmJi2byr.

Alfr@GellXPrgumA Agency (1998)Yvid1norYmۀpachZastrawarnCertai@qdeaҌ3l`markooksftgecip,am,cood)pogenaIs,w`᥁ѓ mp`o' sɁ0suchnatsaflawp(i )ɋxinn0ro@arJP(al􍢍ro8rnBoraXxPqmsel1"likrPȐA)sof\(e.g.0rsomb8effigH)xuBaXinyZ"`NQ lork,ol esihk*ӄ benH׫ 13Մ0cou@hsaiJґBNevheacuH؀y75xdxshowᇹambiguЌowrealp(`hab deQ,nȸas ouswȷI0 YDsdalМaңascx.s.a0ĩmBanalysHKHvalBpړ;ithnograp@s@!,arh |degre숙nQhwhXng؂$m.°hd(pu@wje"failtmehpn]orraybہ˝nؙ|q-'upkHhӆ)m)(\lIpmipevote@qirڶ0-eWXLyimagiy bIw:čQӊcaR𵰨:Newmyc)Gtm`dowiItxse&klxwarɌo".sʑse8#鷈lUDv؇ĉ̔hion@"dc@tt(uR)xrHlultxtra rrȄ que0Ix–ؽ,bexamplhifȚ@Xtinc rbetwe`y‘sȦryRmG'abduvur* (2007,f.1998: 17-21Tԇ!Han؊9BYY!f`whysmoiaxd\'"nvodȥP`MillHصX90tiX,)ޯaonaturalthroposmʅou foBoeo8(xbeHkworrtefacts(583).ndeed,ell’smancipationfhingsyonferrxemithgencyurnsutoeoreimilarMiller thanaytirstppear.he[aiseqerofilewqmakVoperven쁈hu3os8//,actx+.

So,asum:Kikroachexwhicheaontologica0hinc:betweeهandeopunmodifiecannot(.associ.ԃxwhopoinbꀰcommsense77݄1iformaPendowedLЌrkdhity2xlattP.ofoua @ρ 9lMytouhP0`@fi@wayo t#imly;ers }Post-/trast"sAaup0+ch(enge:iypoXafeP@Yusehitae-dexieirerti(i.e.ЀȞB؁`rimHroshdtsel8ncCnkjfrpuc،pàӄn 20041991])@)ntysm`aexc embl`Dklo@8spJrp )׿͔;++uVaLp (e.g.18須IaŔhipQ`invol2}4 awoulguish@om"aȎ)3rgwɃgbck{@[cliccitȟl1cuOgueb{USAxnpeak?furse,rompoiHview,Ase8reimeanlesroolishe(isoF8,th0imodernisthimeraoaiy–ÁƆɃengagnIpf!.nehRrabite(@lHndsk,OJIՇL!\(A:es.)

Yet,@wqsuggtoXjimporه@hanalytz(becaux'l)ensorship.atcmo op`kireturHoynovenX9@akȄth=commitm邈vulg8@se àailler.ndee(ImOsuPstٙingbouHattX2xdisssf9I Jincipl flawӗqcideaayseH@d.t,؁ЀaduchɣC q⤙qutireemeculiХ8orparilceivqJmǘĘ0c zw9i?a Jir`alAQstudixci@sъmutyprlsayXyptZa0on!plpa19rol"h@sop (mpirm,we!follrshexamp,Wsfut}techndemim guko#to8im#has{arhul(mgenc`ф_*harhi+r0eton,loc`ccuЙtribyn-w-a-(sembl.ׄ,ffx)OmaȔt;QQrm (teaФo0i)rojڈBr`non-ouPer`srreducibHhu:8ϪBoyleir-pump20Fty (1993a),#Lsleepyice硲eurv+ip h1Qarafh (C QbPyelY"mYfH3ynptȚr9).

<8e0t="1em"dth="0pt"0x="jufy">A m(Qa@fund_XeHo8whiؐhavepaork.4<Onc(cknowhgeurmpцH脊reve[…yflux?RȜ#rough|
Plo؋ntrajeٵreay0raٲkerI/+dividsh⪹ab0șfa xt0PB8iompouhZalHdorri"74as񬏬RWVpeo0rtolog9Xarbiry,◰adds (c ramongthers)hat,0iseingoye@lutionormancipat񁈀PmustotoindtYanlternventologicalrder (e.g.fActPNetwork),uta9freefromydeXmiiwsoever.TT,n{s,peesiAeconomkliaturehnouaarticul_ris,Bitself-sciousolemicurporoffaorrecjЄomoextremeroponenЃ(w)mmforyoal.etndxterieflyowuttempʁiEwa`upposed)

ApwarIntroduȅІargumXHvolvwoeylaims – eri(0ve@move,ichokiPStn (spabHw9follows.f)g@thnograpstsay1ied,meؑ@lsXsn-|Ùrtefac'qspeakr8auȞ`MelanesigiftѓYrفspi(Ha@’th)̄?c8ona(eu؋,>halyؘ.ӈ8# XbjXXsubmri*ș|eirivityt`؉h bxpopx 0lock(Arejue҂`yo\p8)cric.goheore?; btpmplyqui(earlishackl`ul8akkelo@xbyocʀp"gain,lgencyifгx(g`vablin2Pskadd 'ٮc@PysnewXyQ!z؀ɝgsf(Mil8ex" (GellۡgorassemblX (L@u)x*you.Ҝ*eh"de yoBa؆z8re(ra!Aύȋpad2fQPPacd=1owexiޒ{v (i.tagjf荪study)ZiAu1`򡩅ť{S؆_2il+xqPٟl!Cbe𢉪lam ?iÐQOɃd 3thoughx0@maJȤpa?9sȼ؂ m.

hatowaHddresZj瀞"1 C/)et(ys݌`sp-as-7 TC (ӟęX(poIlaln(on8 a7inRxBe@sI 邂ory#TTTgum@,͂pt 2amaodologrinjunon:ce=ċawp(bfoairȌssuA@mvcapq1rlacXnam–o0bi9fa3yg`2m9b1Yllꁙ[̕ImR1.Ɓˈa.de!inedcampH)Hl` nognmYSs8 (viz.%IngoIdvdi``tAp(;een).o theontrary,p‘things =cepts’ormulasfferedsurrethodologicallauseide-steppustuchqoretzprescriptions.nar؃r,tsuppostoeclpverye0dangXwhencomesqkanthrop5lyboutdintaysn@i:rmayeaturethnograp1,amepthatsm9people"|(remagine,ocistruct).hPɅlternativkoujyspPm–fac1؇(nighl-mancipators r0hrasse8sg0aznertdutetwithari`meanon(byuiahXއonX e a rai8e?eowaecessitxn

S HXIԎYlacaPR.Бpsimply:@ad꘠tll y9in(id8@(modnϋ!qu2defimmed0dvagsissu2z`p0c@dd%liheĖohnda|Vmempsundh"firmbaׂ wwwwNX-as-&tackol upےҢoHpromAHso(narriv➸o2aЊ9eyf儂Ѝoiswoulewȶlpot:ŏsU=nwpharHqua,+mrx'objHifccy2ۘsowYb؇*ߎ؈XR9 analywork9pp`usA@adIntrodpTTTelf,e(llrلpaJre2mHwnpbookIlЇ"sxé .qAua8a-typAfro-Cubd٤YAyalk(hӄir akeX(uR-@@iculPlsehػš: abgr)1iein*9coid,Pargued,r((pone:–sl!݀|(d)߁۸iNow qbviousHaun@-intu8@suggUorh9w0ird (Es-Pritd 1956f.olbra2010)Z k2\qljᆈԔɟfule (it!)mlacу+(aHpoXs1)sί(zscoucault)2beɪڲ!(HclasÚn:M_ZbeXvei`z(dea?0louYמגHr !$9Ӌxio(dȗbetwe|Q厊!b skŤLq9.אdPyДH񂘚'Hr(se0elowShǃ bs̳4kAa9m9H(doexplp?Ȇ1?ggggflvely#treˌTjmQhe`9pЉfir8movegbӢنcpIxjudicwolp`OكWXn.nspҙquestions,hen,ouldeulledromthnographyflldataeordinarilytempt toぁpeople’s ‘beliefsxboutxisowder,ncluhg2notionXatssoier.erJsecondove1TTTod (cept =ing)tresuchaslementsualefini,zues.o:ubanivinersoQvaɆ,∈rar e؇Note,ruciy,owCwa:settup:probises؎sitakesurwefaulsuDž…0dv (itjus`8yˌ:echengw큑o9r!\8hoseeryd@Xiranyhicanalytcoroll(Ldei8etc.…< =)9renIWS-give2͉sona,łHbsurd.ɘڐki7worktǜrmy؎n(IQXrgrou la).

AAimesXmodJs,fonemaghagXack2ong ecipabIe0Xl8itpre.ԘogȐIqu8,argntwoey HffectopeqLspaaZmsel,encpuri*㒟in8КPoctTq9/ifouikermgag".ʓwɊ|)wgpaPJxow!Koeak숷+@langu!exeIyroneed(omp9҄ ct˄$ (%ӕ`H-hmuЏengoldi(canam[ٶa%2)Щ0Ztvo,}ixisHpڂ K[sKUfomeЄex)sHuliar qtxȋaislamboyantxmȗȀhncѦAIodu`ono|fУكcertaiz`jhAthpgleftrgunifiedoooon 1 2ƈirdaw1 ( e)C8with`searcRqueXbyaeologж{8fp`i@o-edito YIOx (Holbraad 2009).e hiAf9s뵉zTheseisgivingsoheeartfjproblemishackl1re,ndreell8lyonnectedaano(rorryatsocialthropologist havadyself (privay!)boutTTTgument,amfac8qanalyticPexperiationsteeks1 motemnneayr bour:ethnographichenoamightroadall ‘magQ’evenani tsenȃ.igtteXmakeoMorsbymsthousȉi(son,aoriSwaziegpaerPia "metysff@cy,hamc0sttranspngolR skieskfami@photSttapiriforcpdaato`powdсiɕXowcrdeit:銘:8th1ribupzourol=@`ghltIeopwhoinmed ߉hm.nmarchae mIusphHW8tptexccidl.ԁlragrk} 0boxso剘ancusdiw`dPta`(e8firinstq,͆ͅ/p:coarasrahazpiiXb-likerKsubj-.

_Xdes8pdef)bbe.till,`тcsoci@ dqbugbXmh0fhXia(prrq?YeRRɇҋŃorhe ,I\op1buitabresrrlphai8Pgivoic€'@ma_irte|fw 3(mute w pitch؀Fwpwrohdiguid hom3w hbegڄaap,twostcnagaϵnXCe9ρϛWacu`xeQ(Vi@astrogorrode-szth΃aZXuJrxvmЬXeX`(becaus~)esup8(seeee` 2007: 8-9,f.on 1998,A2),spaboѲqntempu#?5chhApavIf ¤Ta!penuppa81huself-deiɦB (Z:8ȔWamЗaddu%(*eng)톂pri؆pusoalyrordh!e(ᅹfȅSBQ} ydlQ(bpsunoes0@@ol7o7ve.ndeed,TT’swo-stepethodologyeflectedhisirply.he ‘ng-as-heuristic`ovepenupFsasocusfntIicalelf-determination,hilejconcept =ingqclausellow*ethnographywhatxveondayrouXmorovidetithςyariabPtents.

W8,qIsubstaargum?͂h,Hbedverly,~a`for0opeak,otiPxi؁!ic,utem ?2nger,u!writHspaperlanthrehxamplXanopQarchaenalys{i8rdexplorque؄(r5<!t؂c@ivm$yield prepa9耨sursfi(hsu*Sn 2005).T,+:5cҤQoɋXyӒhi㛐go(KoK)_ςɚ?is.ԅῡ"4ow3ٳ0@utͲجPHge8u0uchl0whyRaflSitstaABracke دunlg!drwhiwqo`!/ =kxmulamdir@ʥJbl@@.p9needdoI遊bwar ( school(l9symmetreqty):hIPe*AerɉrevHe (k*JpeRadvoca9expliciQ؎ЁB0?adesJ*ossibirhZpeopȢJxaroPntde憠:KrH̚rendP ΐPӅFczwu(analysnow,ߝH)Aоit suo@፸Qphra"afd@e'''''in䮨rgIA9Hw@d`Powflesr>ixIngoldskosqueerXCaYsXw)lQ٘Bmpيy0٬@hPpg @ ethnograpA9.avempd’fnyonceptualresuppositionsfhata9untဨne,eilltackpithlternativelisdrawnromhtingeethnographicatandrdP.ne`describRprocedur؄strikesQouldeaorm‘empiric0ology’herexnotits_Yg8.oaask:isequivalHly΁Areverse0IeekohticulateAs?ollowghȂsymmetrour4al-@Pgy,:answeranyfoni;m`richaracisp:Belf.ׅwabout (drxn)deedustowsHcletsa(prag@lda#΅)orstuff)ɂ feeix7z48yhmam#Ph@heumark ?Ԃv()iffHzsspnoorpheard eopldy2,⋘ɂar,(mellXas touc(gAŝ@()s.

‡֣Ingold,owyxÈl phm (inc!ditmHe`99Șsnsuous"exploڒmuڣnmesh@󌔂organxPZ@Safda(pbroad0eclivBJsraisqueHh\ǁ)epeem ؅׈ћ GoǜlrЯɁ:nctIpr7.sufouki;ahoriz`ff0lʐ_ jfXT`mQmagѷZxҌxoGthti!fun,ɁdЗ†ЎnsX҇A ("or grrexhipws^ف i(zHusserl)imp pumoveJwould񊪚ibclook (divor눩dnZhtweenre(hsIndɲ& =rlaus0aXy{mod|sugg0yyǜ%ډxshpos7n\ilit aс݉icompre(h皑`,0ɁXPelfٓ"QٱinusƤRڵeechog):ϳti0s,σystaboBa+a@lf-_ras}ImYc(awaewak*ak:`p0iloso8wفphɂp@c(ڥ0L@asu?Sex؝؉`s": ;dhdalidea_speakhavamȆHʜI(aQurIdҬl1hW露+rubHc`thrLeibnizuDeleuzmanQevablemstill,dopgؤ^venpNslrecoarilynӨZYonneJ(1991),ͯHPeHI elsewri8staiwOcapacכXٓam#PЃø(popcve):xBacqui Pnr[zGنw-a-(seeolbraad &edersen 2009).atherhanovZisroundgainorreturposes,owe,lyinghatKki8ofnalytical8malooksikeitheferenceoexampleachéichbeghdiscussarlier. (Indeed,ntrospectxteemsmarkabllinjarguwasaste bnotnlyInductioJTTT,8xɂow؃s`xpHus@Pillustraweaw,utvmyw`hapt CbXectuXs(maiЀ`carriut.)

If,IavxqpromY(mancip(Yqassocihethnography(ontologYdve2B;>xertpQnstȐr.e\lreadXeen,ڕ4JeeryFar`devoyxsolvq–momalsobe?{Ptdrn:qWoldeadihtA֏sfatarfra(aЇXelopLjitselwel rt2Wlua.ruЇsi)ڇLb(ч8^depend@L1yttempulqueinv@$sariouisP?=.PnutshvidcRAfro-Cubatocosmaj’sp)!я$c@isDabilityPowiabitiذdur GemonX7Ӆpif`ĂI‘s irbsXaRsurfa醣boar@ ahpodduhssai be,Ary.ϭP+gxsA[…]YwiJbackd L8)9ou9A-r,cooutZ*mc;T`cxlyCScapacdmakeۘ<]'"yAhsagdLduz9phBcharactɠrco3u臠tu2blH–3ultiplii`aA'>Tbabalawoцvraonfigurxt騾ns :o`ovH(kdispldiArchd0thwr)ˏmdso.Ԅ5xOKxeaupp^G@i/reg.ۖway],pm "re@#ex[MXoey;simp(Re-grorsal:wX#Eveaفaaempora`勷{0q@sugaԄMcgo#h׭ft ser]ڔoG_ireTZaché-)sͬt!sisplacementsfowderellssomethingrettymportantbouthemise Ifáosmology:a*seeiti0areo0hought[nos]nt:,rar motions.…]xodduрjusP,qnappAnomy1givaicaliorixtranscendencevrelarisassolved.nႆunie݁Hmve,؉looksik ǃbecsis(andƁuprox ySo,yquarʍhaven)wi msesbcapac䃊humxqrِotdirectedv҄JI]aché-lgua teHalugenuinAoblem9r%m#orjbXhpsdyZ. (Holbraad 2007:08-9)I cciIsZanalysH(i.e.5shiptweёwimq)cursHlydiformH9tbcep) nographicngs) –!jrlt(aduch.ȋ,owe, w1onPfocxxtqueponxorawXworkdo 08yrtuepecif񃠄mrch0ric؇yrr)2E,Îrgu󃞝 lǑ(vxlocruceR1Ur sEȥԚcaf(92pauȁir7ifHsZAp8։aur02rg€s①Mxupwy2smarked:perviohpuultipliƒu؅,10ațڟI~,̦wYrehOx=Isq>(er’Ч8so.ūFsPK7:A{ wN=nqtizoff Hsetgi(Ȟгpomw‘afdhěrP`l7|+2ՀvrI;ivot2Mn,p,aZ?fraï4p 3j8" =clPنpspIubmiakY)loufaxrWWRTed.

Clus:ognd/ pragP>:By‰ASBmbthrxatt8e=ndwbkimvoicˇ?77Iasouढu˥#qimp(*ora Hc@bouZ`grQ(Hrcʅizcou)‚Le0cipXcmbuchdeonHtempiobjHw0ep𝋤"a@?TcorrspIsuggℰbitbullet.ojexaejP fro-ZeXdoYem trÉ̑VowXc菉1o #0nureXrmYservi؏$܋pro@@whÁЛAably,I(lɂPscepticism{gsquareڃ71(Is-c rx9Y܌.Ɋ꘰admit0tayHeniW0eQ tur8 a*ʐ#2involiduciI-ɑ8orhɇI)ab8gm0,rrow someRseco0elg1„蟧Chr8opWitm ((thH)WS؉diffeOhkx󟭢Ptgaug reOm@agZy燸Ppփ_oPNjdo=multiraiQ (`gisuiefie8inquiry.צצצצAllQȲXulȻf0bsurلmAul.͉")g @udiscipihri pi0*Baqu"hi!lˑPunmedHbruncheck8my?;asoI?힡у#0dĈ&lookІ8hazoP(Ç!!d!earli𛀇PInk@Fenougxo vidmodelPfPxbecahs@poslҽYƅiXbl)eꆪorw[or)mod u8ef{Ľ[ph cShnsrrclo,ihmtppnti81,e(,aradZ}" rރ)un`rsStilH:ӡpadí0@aspg Țus` () KctCpoathoup7rȁ izʱA؜@rp2noas1ou?x (¿"xclusx0ofxaРm ì`enI؂@:spto`mnsaIhs )geЄkoQ'؞involh?8@*truс u,cbroaӅȔ;labԍsuphвss@bYKgeق)8LHЅili9work5'i0؂teȄXrʓ.Ѓgbackwardssa/ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSς???=VRppabeeesÈdepartmentaleminarsnberdeen,OASndCL,sellAathe Thing(SpiritsonferenceLisbon (Septem 2010)EAGʀX i/Bristol.Ɂankameseach,ńimpsoVictoruchli,icardooquPJoaoasceloDanicks脸irespectiv9vitationsXoparticipantyfmWaluablemme`Aamlsorateful`ehilipsenillutXversSurwȀ@.


REFERENCESڂAppaaArju1986. ‘Introduon:odhpolcsIe’peociLife!3:ÂgaCultlЉLɄ. (ed.).ambridgenHrsityА, 3-63oooonrgyrouasso2002.iAnthroogyWaMean:ostc0ncyha.ondIPluEngelkMatw 7 omA霁:eyӄXp :AfrphurchBerkeley:yiC0.Evans-Pch()5(Nu8Re0KNework &xd:D}FowleSe8i8perfubj@pltudؗjPaAnnuCo;ore0Ahae+GHp3May 24ob@',vOOOOH---10Peopwithou霁AH_!Abd8zrcendXLoetҞ0s9:er@3-41GGGGEGhPlfre9pQrAgؖ׆ьzy5ClaHoooojuyIJan0`3Wealthp self-li3quaapMa.S. 28(2):3-265HarawaDonna. (81))ixHyborgCWo@:a8𸨅iNacFreeBookP''''armaGraham"9BNetw BrunuPMetaphysЎRe.pw????8enp9rHolbraaďPWastC̠3ink0@gh^"isartefactsthnogr(Al,ׄrwwRle 1-31χrt5.xp1mhiplic:oney#bIfásrJnfRoyɜ72IntutR () y11S31-54ggggowxHdermomdivinyosm (oraaagainAHEߏ189-22׉xOnt,hhaO:f؜xdokFCambriHS|"19(344WWWWWۆ=s(o8rЕpp1c.ebDiscuss)(fromDAT8,Venkhs@.)PritiquҘg 302179-18gggLatour,runo, 1993. Weaveevereenodern.ranslatedy.orter.ondon:rentic1ll.

NOTES
2.hrisill0(whosxwnuhsm-bangffor drawpinlyhenogy),u itosimply,!defencR!ip‘materixty’:T copt)ysquir)ecautriessiderJembrasubj-o:la sobeyلbrut[th8s] whert/)XirxopхX@mp8apXpeople. (2007: 17)">3.n؉pt͂r,orhe,s2aa0rlabo`etapboutiloso8ca`heel Dhve8lyhelpoich؏,ٜmind,xsr@r# hiptweeewnalytdems (ss5: 43-46????94.Ԝ"exiPyiatounKspysslag:ac9s{#ok𒠣cƒ Reemscu81ar195.yav)cidPe؃sthofha icst蠘n͐polia (%(1131؈efpsɈvzQmselves,t3a Battag@/fbick-ax(F 199WPs̗__Ƞ [ext#NrchaeFdebYskeuosm,r(I ,v}ea o9zrans`pri0P@a؅(謉— bs0LdivP2mbp:pXbrX/body>INDX TAGX 000A IDXTINDXX 00000退0001>熀0002[yн0003U.׀0004<0005?0006@0007B0008F0009H000AJIDXT+9GIntroEmancipation as the entanglement of persons and thingsRethinking through thingsConclusion: anthropology and/or pragmatologyReferencesNotes12345JFIFHHC     C   P&!"#&1! ?|k{uk57#1peWƟ6,F!LGzLrUWn؛a}\8=mbQM;Hk}MЏ_0BDV RjY-+,(IF628db_*DNVw1N6^JVXi*ZaT3f/ 5TFJ ?/BtiVHle ȳp{K#"1H'iN[SD6ԲTJk_E_2p00أ-sTyֱG5gpu͕cKsj]?^30:ζ%-j iU+y=`SD&nꆼVuMM(+ ΏjZbpEr =W=_$,Kp[(:Ѡ@!&D8a.`NTJES7,Х׼ P yr !P>5D%H8莌rҸ'a9=j1n,>xkD˨,bcNJvr{QJFIFvv XICC_PROFILE HLinomntrRGB XYZ  1acspMSFTIEC sRGB-HP cprtP3desclwtptbkptrXYZgXYZ,bXYZ@dmndTpdmddvuedLview$lumimeas $tech0 rTRC< gTRC< bTRC< textCopyright (c) 1998 Hewlett-Packard CompanydescsRGB IEC61966-2.1sRGB IEC61966-2.1XYZ QXYZ XYZ o8XYZ bXYZ $descIEC http://www.iec.chIEC http://www.iec.chdesc.IEC 61966-2.1 Default RGB colour space - sRGB.IEC 61966-2.1 Default RGB colour space - sRGBdesc,Reference Viewing Condition in IEC61966-2.1,Reference Viewing Condition in IEC61966-2.1view_. \XYZ L VPWmeassig CRT curv #(-27;@EJOTY^chmrw| %+28>ELRY`gnu| &/8AKT]gqz !-8COZfr~ -;HUcq~ +:IXgw'7HYj{+=Oat 2FZn  % : O d y  ' = T j " 9 Q i  * C \ u & @ Z t .Id %A^z &Ca~1Om&Ed#Cc'Ij4Vx&IlAe@e Ek*Qw;c*R{Gp@j>i  A l !!H!u!!!"'"U"""# #8#f###$$M$|$$% %8%h%%%&'&W&&&''I'z''( (?(q(())8)k))**5*h**++6+i++,,9,n,,- -A-v--..L.../$/Z///050l0011J1112*2c223 3F3334+4e4455M555676r667$7`7788P8899B999:6:t::;-;k;;<' >`>>?!?a??@#@d@@A)AjAAB0BrBBC:C}CDDGDDEEUEEF"FgFFG5G{GHHKHHIIcIIJ7J}JK KSKKL*LrLMMJMMN%NnNOOIOOP'PqPQQPQQR1R|RSS_SSTBTTU(UuUVV\VVWDWWX/X}XYYiYZZVZZ[E[[\5\\]']x]^^l^__a_``W``aOaabIbbcCccd@dde=eef=ffg=ggh?hhiCiijHjjkOkklWlmm`mnnknooxop+ppq:qqrKrss]sttptu(uuv>vvwVwxxnxy*yyzFz{{c{|!||}A}~~b~#G k͂0WGrׇ;iΉ3dʋ0cʍ1fΏ6n֑?zM _ɖ4 uL$h՛BdҞ@iءG&vVǥ8nRĩ7u\ЭD-u`ֲK³8%yhYѹJº;.! zpg_XQKFAǿ=ȼ:ɹ8ʷ6˶5̵5͵6ζ7ϸ9к<Ѿ?DINU\dlvۀ܊ݖޢ)߯6DScs 2F[p(@Xr4Pm8Ww)KmC        Y  ! 1AQ2a"#bq8BRv$Wr34567Sds%9CTc&Gfu?4DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD_Ny$llgWMQt#' d?V=GW*"""""".xa ddhV3zz{PiDev IZ]z7LM=ltFa-[IF~,f;Ǐiv2ӭy8Ӵ ˼!Z'VkOyHNK g?8m$SVOG#dHCyi,ݷ{ܝIn$ݼŵG#FX)Ӯ];cyxzgg8Mz:SRCEPr1s}UYLTDDDDT -Sxϻ-/DLJ CttOT0Sˋ|{)ϴo>mcxuFʦ3918>7}f89ү4DDDDEBpx۴u_5]\(8ڴ|\l*-J:ƺKKǸk׼|lkihz'֊ Oh,?^5O[Ӭ.s݌~enWߥ9;~q1}ӑ^*=e 3.#MX{QְBdiw9[]](OK>}Mbx I jxiZ%=t~.>+2d*""".%8ZGiWFOw,,a_^柞m?[x]o ]G+`i9!:( 9Vpo|?GdO39c*鉫`p |Tlh!4M6טnGI'hV8u||A UQjͨ 2pf݊!{Z>_뛮kkNjkje>qq  ~ƞ#}fn?GSw  ak@!Rs*""".%> T М-A=MY\b::AuyCGYgUMA,FL4ޜ~äQo+!$nk#)eq_O=GMKiQҵow#IA{:*""\yT`vKj.{W ۛ9zijgtrDMI3{KI\Q<Qg>:>ax-emWM_rbcëOPBNҼTm>Sz +>2XVЂb*KOvvnWKl _ nB^~27F)W6n j)k-du.aii'lZwltַ{'.a;1?y""..$Txv7g~mc%+霯b>H} R.H|q8i1]-V{;iIuIzJdi\\8rI_""""-n*&k{NXϻI/YiPaҿ8֏n%ZjJSxU>S'Ʒ h+Iʒ>)%ҚޯgoՇkWd2Z2z Z3g0=$DE=|G횫uwgߠa/#QNQ˶zS{:wgsNKO\2<+vnzMk#&Tɉ礑1?z""Ws,?zY_m6ZGAo4W{~5Ƣ\nQysi#U h3TDDDDE=}_oiߢ""(wM'vڌ0_nczH`($DDDDDDEimIqڒ~T>lv#,l^Qo^i-so A|Tı=_-ڴ^mszp4Vz7 /qZMۓ/Pj+je9|@Dv4").b:{=H} R~ xQqEOimT^ ais)?#%7}5S~N^3AjA+}JJBN@cDDDDDDDE2G:DTL6v[ORp#T"':uj$d[PvnWKo%"GN.7F2""pnUtiZiߓ朖ծi`&wl4޶H$^TN=$Yi^Upp$^r7MHno$} xf~VDDDDDE=}_oiߢ""wsTQ5+~p+{\K%qDDDDDDDE ]֎#%-ph= 3]'SJ ># ۵lvj]sz QYP"./Q7=jgruU_*UwVI[S+rgyJ?cO|٫WTݬBGt= >jWó"+;x_i "Y\3x.Y_;^9$WDDDDD[ULM"", k"ђ4KF=""""""""-좬u'H ;g@S҈(KEeٻ-Vi-|Kvs~=dogx""+mwZ3wk-du>9?U-#<޷HnQ] đ;1?*y׾!,Y-a^t7}5S~ k~RDijc.yDDDDDDDD[3m5hKIns/ w۟3"vm[]^E 6jXèrx>c\|ZyDDDDDD[ULM"".]i m.'Xy~['ܪjbKV-p (h\\F] 6JG_Ҧ8 =Wy=|GݞtsOq ^G#DDDEsm^j *wgikZG$/I;6 5r/TQ11$nxsOť^ ҃]^ӄs|f$.`yk-s0ZApDDDDDE=}_oiߢ""}vC]u@D6Hr5Te'xߵkb"""""""@*o{ vM ښ^IXaEQ~6B>oR+|nձ{QجoB]Q/Q4_kk;ުԺxROW z DDDD@HRĀ޶fSU\{xz6@?B>@>T6MpHnOi><|/b"""""-n*&k{NG'lk np;eƆW|ן%#T9DDDDDDExݷsֈFdcaHN_#}WmwlZ^gcewˋ=H!򶢳lݚ4[wG9A%zE興]m^jf.iW 0JjޝZyת6U1LJ4BB-}}K8]]O!>b0z{ɚөDDD]>ֽmnzJMҖJ:iD=9Twz/*%lsp+(IAZ,BF """"""ӱtՊz5R#C000+ |wrձKEft툜!u{Z>p5ruU_'5W{dRp+}v5q hn7꫞b7hd>jX<%kn~kou/TrRN48t{}Ӈ{7}-PY_j,lܤ29{H? 7}5S~v{ok %#`p%O ;ܘ4`T{w+ =ntU,pZG DDDDDEWQ nl5J1[-Զu5 4Tt42)`c"kG@=ָܭ'THƣl垧4[wG9A 0|ou*]} ]bwVG[N"򟃆ZG+vnzMk{#oQ2DH柈WUZiAKxg󍧡s7yԮ?88s۫gJj$tR3K_p 7}5S~i֎)ԺsۙEl5ܣhF<doq5꫆%CE[9^8d #+jx(/U_}TKهT~t4"u}p:mwh]JiK\V!~8q=KRI%]=ݛVm>Wجn/@kG-ozPjkj'qq  ]""""""(KN0?-mnm$4.6wɵx=L4]m5+UI5 },zZIp湧 `ik%~GGot:Rz5'%?{8dg+%ݦvM =Ga @ִ}踓:(GGf5Qu%2|1\B~# y7('(M}v}`)k-dus 0H^vot;ӵo[XoѲ.ɉǣwcÚ~-*ʪ[_~.*庹LkPQ}>Gr†">oW%6<@ 5ȉO<5 uXL"""/g\:}Cpe5 Z/xMs~-<ګL~ua>7wq~˾wPuUƸ@ h>z뎗n͗:隆)%{=~.i'iv&zf@mژR_K0oy{\~$5k3K cv_O3O9ÿb)9$MRH8tx-_u>!o>欷!7TKSش3KJB->Ž ^j뎬n -\e8|AgطkcCljP_JpQ:FhY~IQzO$LhKP8b7ruT_vWU^/VK\/{8.,|g޿W&W'T7տ IU> &W/O}M[_q^T'O}=[_ᅦIU>#޿W&W'T7V'W&W''W&W/AfT\W,߁տ I{'_ju  +TG R6h hkʑvU|KM QAq9lH5>ivvKMQ_YU7yIvmID\|;1 H+z4ɦ+,ډ*1s+^5O[e{n{Q@o-U3Ag$9NKMCN}0X+?{$ m$=tYCjehohTHumnv'L!xGкצ.q J0=:F~տ–Fش>VuwjgnYoz*"""""""""""AO01TDDDDDDDDDDDTO9e2UELS)s*"8@sꀂ@rBS(S)*]cY3(/k\qQ_'\IQmzp5^6@P3r|79- ]MSzLɢH>7xJꍊ{S]h쬾ﶘDA󱥎=AO|Ao~tzvͣϡA=۟ 1́#9.9sדMo]sKtU_ EE4s9k0Hnyڃbg7(lbna,p fAh cMw}oS;{<)P6Z׺OyR,hIY{^qSgFMjQNGfd)k^-%#<>k=Зu( %|-s$z^n[c:[i)06Yok\\xI9FpYڮOoQ[Cpk?"3 sqX?ixo7fwraԚSvl4Y owխoy z,Dѧ]&d #ػ]M[k˫/7ŊSGŽ9Z fğ_i6}eUgv`:h#N[Zcs#CF0t/+W/|mq#tZ+fka*`x49cĆm|1ص֍%VICKimx掙Q-n@H'!cw{_'bgUK/6&iiqܬ`s~k Z{I2?m^ZKکhsdi:6{zad}Vg݂ kETSFS4; O)||V&nFM?]\VٽO-; x<}7^qiuMYlt׈Q>7g>lzx ħSMHH|eH7-x2=nF{C{ Ͷ]C:Z͙K98Y#_XoXk7/ouݮǡmv(5\RT̍/đ.nnZv:7SXE־kckkȻ4~[/b-ǻܣӶVetp/tYW}܍DܴeWݨ-u ρsK@/h=د.[UkwqlOo䣢҈HG\R4xe;+z?}ڊH'ۻM#ǿE)z[)#BEx_B-=83=)-+l⋇kmklzzgF%T9hϊʝ6: v/v^9! -kGLaj}p#'y9l?i`|uFnQ}N+s͌2 8|@ s05{\~s#X;o:*|WS  ^:vťsS;@?dUn3ؙUC?o{d:V=,Zif,HL/<%|vZ+ }Pte<12FgЖat5l_Di{SqClS@F v ~.qsīhaݩKO@B._Akd$uPR9qbэ.VwsY-E,x\ˤ~iwґKTW6)|Cbni6${pZw"!203uY """88UEVR]M55Dmf:9#wF? fvP69wR6Avb-!=c2sܜ',7 2nioit #Lv0"=~ş˺x- {nt5лYaշI.U4V8psrge!Jo톙ֆ;\k/4W\Ǹ;)G9c|< ۬vŨ[[< .o14}99ׯUӺ3K\Km^tTu }җI1Bগe-ڷ_cݪ2RK$Ysa rs|_ oj\#O7Caucu,tcO%).7kw>v/_EbOl.q<Ic?×~%/ v}wbu+.tT( tG2|: 7e $en͛?^BY;~\c-,? tMo7:ROx`4ddM-9z ?+Iϳ~}ܽYtn]٭j5,Xkr2uÈYo_phpUZ^l6⡦[+{Ao3q*ោefYi eRR("dp ߮ΪOtV-ciE#,7č0Zr2O$,I®;Hit@*!;xc=1lg}OUk]һiLZj0B?dwІ-nz ,/sqOHoӲK]OY3#$7>9Yo"AB_ޚZx1nV^ pNJ#^Z\m#ӏF9 ˄m.nS~o+\ԒKI>ʊkڨ7Zj; ya9-dy$cNt[*6YtĖ~X[rzz1 U^;kPE__ţ ]Г{<[vmLOmmً]Ncl 9{{=B ~16%=V:>Bdao9nFq ?pC l2m.'EO4_gmMqa7eS${.@8͂/ 0ݸcٛށV2EmU]Fch #a==֚:QO]uWFh C&c{OwI eS)0P۩~4͐Ҿ7sw\;Y+* nm4Whnu1l{yCC9]g \=n^]s-uOlѲ^^-"=\03TTL&`z&rDLNQ9G`&`&`z&0 `z&a0=US0=0 NQקrNQ蜣0 JFIFHHC    #%$""!&+7/&)4)!"0A149;>>>%.DIC; K  !1AQ"aBq#26RVt3bru$578sCSc?~T".c઄$1Cu%r'_}D3" y*584PVVI!Z\:uRA\m\O+ڮ/ 6T15yUZkK&Au+1-mi>xz}q̼5. {EӍ IEVF^sf_FJ~*rR/FBIFE4\nVU"̷o[~A|Pmn&O3@dWޖ)HSN~-.'^8Ur\sN]Vk\IG%<,273KiMŜԩłٸlqGPh 2妦}*J^h()c($c. {z2(gV>%>'RHԤT%/].)şyEQ̅^_ٿ$FF{i2hQ#-ѐYq5y.J)<:;-#ԟ:YqMVE r U–+dX3="~n-e2eABS)CQ136S*M{T(訿^C-+xQPUe}U1 RZrvҘ91`J|  {)5)zZEjq\GuETyjSd.i>i><vtTMG~A`?qu_Cuթn,JZ&>&f?ómV=@c+ ]ZI\fZG%< ZߒḵS1p2vE%s4.;ZY@|)1'eE ~E9kSR֣Ry5as t0Wk1IuYg6k2".<*ZUr&9zY] qC9mw%6Or/A  #+m.=̡=+eI {)U)zjEq\Gu}EUyjSD/|^"XƢReT+U͚wpVUUY3vB䐞I.,ƀ A?W?2C cO·X^yL#CˎC8QrQHuWj@UgJ̋W^0+Q͚s>'R"Q>Zߒḵw( AN-.n^__PSw ÷X^6$s" ? A?W?2C}ηzU&oK Asm̥YT'YE RZrvض9cJQe'#ω {)U)4zZEjq\ר*-IlEOyKd1\뗭RnsmOdas t0 jgIHq8z&cFf{t4ػ3Ɇgb1j=BU8͚s褻C*U Zߒḳ3P.-.vWi/ӑ \u ;8x9I3Qgas t0 wHv mE^Pmf#II>ӕӷŵzV̻)-$* TQꑪQg yr:j%R)-ȳ''G 5"mhU'ۂG, A?W?2CMK&p?adr2HͲ&_pVc)uY&[8͚WC*U Z%8y@\Z uls_~_H֑[7t}[Io?%R?ras t05B*gSeCW 1~il<,-T] ?-M@7n:.xz_L^D GNWN\{j3CzV9˲<RGũDV'}|=Gu}EUyfKD/|^"Z|.>Q2iQaDx2>BX :s1oʋ$V/J%50!к*es]ApO,pˆޡKI?٫W?-^Kx!)* k5%qw( AN-+_Gٿ$@{t;֩ WU/_<ǵӕXv q+ {蔙J\TN dYӠLƁ:i-=B R:rvض9cJYe'-$* TQꑪQg yr:z%R)MȾ#HdwN2mGeLHR,m|_\ m,{ٓiR)o =f2gO>1wJTH˹淇I&[xvzp6G2ҿgQ'+O(T*)5 k~Kqggqh2ٽ"ْe̿Xi/ .*.5j&-:IlвY]rCm$Ҧ'G^ XܴQw `as t0fm[Fʢ{AC4̉"bKeLʍ6ːݴma;xU(R)QTF ^YiC-!-I)BK-DC )9];y1˲B0TR*1g yr:W^ĪE?,OyHdJ6]4yM̻cBqMBfJJF\Hϟ @4h|s QIV{ySR |uǐꭷ _y@nv}dLQte*NfOa,Fe:B}pVc)iF[8͚W̋rJ|JEBZߒp<.];7[2\칗/M%$AI.M|QJ*E qI.e-Sn6Jˉas t0 vhMAWFMIos.Eۣ L%),$Ty>:W^ĪE<)Y~I##x ujE2:)(kȮr (Z4^x}a/%[,!&(٢=h5WjL]u4eosy_G; lHn Z ,o7F}L IKUyIPhW%?pfh|oe(zw6xU??}ѽ2$~&C9OН-IDne΋LcKV\ZdH3 BPcy=*1MY?<9nAHwdf2rEc6UH.Q[\77woڏ(<»~>;CaݿWjpav 0߫Pyv]}P Q0߫Pyv]}woڇ(<û~>;CaݿWjpPƆpQڕDRfFZQ%*qŦ$|e )C-$ddc@43mUԧտ7?W]gȵyjfb{ƭ2źɬ*VAt>ezI%Aኳrʠe:) Ke3ϸn](.WjE͘_,~Π[ ҩʹ0q^3 2$@@@ $ $CɏחVkxwg>f*E] YEz| N䏞Z땋es?[),a:,`^, \-~%+f!拁I>OIiJg5%ԶFff3!.^U wu9Dx>uU:Hn۷BrZߪgȆcGUBA6s)VhK,x ^J̜)yoW=qkMW(WCZA+rfDy#4kUsc,a:E]zryT*Łn!?rxN]̢M\tJ$\|Fn~uM%z?V1IUQYg>Ӈ>YqG%3k=+SٝѮʙp[*’6I*c8.׈Uz!%Rh"ٸkc>UUZAdQIl~r-qיiV#ͨN*KBK;D!TZ]&Pu pq)?pӟg/E$'%&xϤ[φ^-Me'&m">y Y ]q]0/5.MqP$8<dp#3hnWMb#|$fgc]|)~WG?ݻ5h&g/v]5Of:B%$ѧ%1ӝ='JI FF^ ܧJi#ű .c&+o)55VuZ%1$R mL\}.Tq O.?{gh~ :\ݬQ|q[K(4#ywFȻiVꔷ^K7ui:#3"!E&bOJԧ"3gl[:z.= v[CNJ32ݓ3ϴcK2 .e,4m!iO 'kF ֦Tiu4ԒH2l(h|$vFy:뭼k .ZPWU ꥮχBC?|ZRS(CCFX vk9٠,^I\èCLA3&%4Y|H%cfYZ09:d6X5~1 ١ȑӒ[8mi@mρ]Rީev E(u*kbӎ {O'd Z~To,%sds2,VZ]&[ khiήK-#z[F);<{a8}TnGe%ƧC(Ew0m)"H%oWfJ"~#FicG-w'ǥ:n0b2ݞNgY]CLy#2<:0 ")L#:d[ -RU,Z_y2c Fgn/Jзu1X”/geMƊ= MK[c.j7{쭭D2 XYp H `00`H0 `FLISAFCIS(